Disharmonization of Supreme Court Regulations in Material Judicial Rights

Taufik Hidayat(1), Resti Dian Luthviati(2*), Suviwat Jenvitchuwong(3),

(1) Faculty of Law, Universitas Gadjah Mada, Yogyakarta
(2) Demographic and Civil Registration Study Program, Universitas Sebelas Maret, Surakarta
(3) Faculty of Law, Thammasat University, Bangkok
(*) Corresponding Author


This study aims to analyze the problems with Supreme Court Regulation in Judicial Review resulting from inconsistencies in these rules, which impact the court's ability to enforce these regulations. This study is a normative legal analysis. The findings of this study indicate that the problem of discordant norms in judicial review is related to two factors, specifically discordant norms regarding the authority to examine formal matters. The discord of norms about the legal subject matter of the Petitioner for Review of Legislation under the Act results from differences in regulation of judicial review material aspect used as a criterion. This contradicts the original intent of the Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.

Full Text:



Aji, Adiguna Bagas Waskito, Puji Wiyatno, Ridwan Arifin, and Ubaidillah Kamal, ‘Social Justice on Environmental Law Enforcement in Indonesia: The Contemporary and Controversial Cases’, The Indonesian Journal of International Clinical Legal Education, 2.1 (2020), 57–72

Anggono, Bayu Dwi, and Fahmi Ramadhan Firdaus, ‘Omnibus Law in Indonesia: A Comparison to the United States and Ireland’, Lentera Hukum, 7.3 (2020), 319–36

Avdasheva, Svetlana, Svetlana Golovanova, and Yannis Katsoulacos, ‘The Role of Judicial Review in Developing Evidentiary Standards: The Example of Market Analysis in Russian Competition Law Enforcement’, International Review of Law and Economics, 58 (2019), 101–14

Barr, Michael S., and Geoffrey P. Miller, ‘Global Administrative Law: The View from Basel’, European Journal of International Law, 17.1 (2006), 15–46

Bedner, Adriaan, ‘Consequences of Decentralization: Environmental Impact Assessment and Water Pollution Control in Indonesia’, Law and Policy, 32.1 (2010), 38–60

Cohen, Alon, ‘Independent Judicial Review: A Blessing in Disguise’, International Review of Law and Economics, 37 (2014), 209–20

Daniel K. Tarullo, ‘Bank Supervision and Administrative Law’, Columbia Business Law Review, 2022.1 (2022)

Davis, Peter Alexander Earls, ‘Decrypting Australia’s “Anti-Encryption” Legislation: The Meaning and Effect of the “Systemic Weakness” Limitation’, Computer Law and Security Review, 44.September 2018 (2022), 105659

Dubinsky, William, Daniel A. Farber, and Philip P. Frickey, Law and Public Choice: A Critical Introduction, Michigan Law Review, 1992, xc

Eviningrum, Sulistya, and Vasco Fronzoni, ‘The Model of Coaching Narcotics Prisoners in the Correctional Penitentiary’, Journal of Human Rights, Cul ture and Legal System, 2.2 (2022), 78–86

Fatma Ulfatun Najicha, Lego Karjoko, I Gusti Ayu Ketut Rachmi Handayania, Rosita Chandrakirana, and Dian Furqani Tenrilawa, ‘The Conceptualization of Environmental Administration Law in Environmental Pollution Control’, Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 2.2 (2022), 87–99

Gaffar, Salahuddin, Agus Mulya Karsona, Yani Pujiwati, and Indra Perwira, ‘The Concept of Procedural Law Regarding the Implementation of Collective Agreements with Legal Certainty in Termination of Employment in Indonesia’, Heliyon, 7.4 (2021), e06690

De Gregorio, Giovanni, ‘Democratising Online Content Moderation: A Constitutional Framework’, Computer Law and Security Review, 36 (2020), 105374

Gregorio, Giovanni De, ‘Digital Constitutionalism in Europe Reframing Rights and Powers in the Algorithmic Society’, Gastronomía Ecuatoriana y Turismo Local., 1.69 (1967), 5–24

Harijanto, Andry, Siti Hatikasari, and Juliet Musabula, ‘The Model of Legal Protection for Children Victims of Domestic Violence Based on Justice Elimination of Violence Against Women . 2 Indonesia Has Ratified the United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women ( Conve’, Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 2.2 (2022), 100–112

Hartanto, Dadang, Juhriyansyah Dalle, A. Akrim, and Hastin Umi Anisah, ‘Perceived Effectiveness of E-Governance as an Underlying Mechanism between Good Governance and Public Trust: A Case of Indonesia’, Digital Policy, Regulation and Governance , 23.6 (2021), 598–616

Huda, Ni’matul, Dodik Setiawan Nur Heriyanto, and Allan Fatchan Gani Wardhana, ‘The Urgency of the Constitutional Preview of Law on the Ratification of International Treaty by the Constitutional Court in Indonesia’, Heliyon, 7.9 (2021), e07886

Ishak, Nurfaika, and Romalina Ranaivo Mikea Manitra, ‘Constitutional Religious Tolerance in Realizing the Protection of Human Rights in Indonesia’, Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 2.1 (2022), 31–44

Isra, Saldi, and Hilaire Tegnan, ‘Legal Syncretism or the Theory of Unity in Diversity as an Alternative to Legal Pluralism in Indonesia’, International Journal of Law and Management, 63.6 (2021), 553–68

Jaelani, Abdul Kadir, and Muhammad Jihadul Hayat, ‘The Proliferation of Regional Regulation Cancellation in Indonesia’, Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 2.2 (2022), 121–38

Junaedi, Junaedi, ‘Efforts to Prevent Bureaucratic Corruption Based on the Piercing Principles of the Governance Veil in Realizing Good Governance and Clean Governance in Indonesia’, Journal La Sociale, 1.2 (2020), 10–16

Karakas, Leyla D., ‘Political Rents under Alternative Forms of Judicial Review’, International Review of Law and Economics, 52 (2017), 86–96

Karjoko, Lego, I Gusti Ayu Ketut Rachmi Handayani, Abdul Kadir Jaelani, and Muhammad Jihadul Hayat, ‘Indonesia’s Sustainable Development Goals Resolving Waste Problem: Informal to Formal Policy’, International Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning, 17.2 (2022), 649–58

Marsden, Chris, Trisha Meyer, and Ian Brown, ‘Platform Values and Democratic Elections: How Can the Law Regulate Digital Disinformation?’, Computer Law and Security Review, 36 (2020), 105373

Mohamad Faiz, Pan, ‘Perlindungan Terhadap Lingkungan Dalam Perspektif Konstitusi Environmental Protection in Constitutional Perspective’, Jurnal Konstitusi, 13.4 (2016), 766–87

Prasetyo, Ngesti, Moh Fadli, Tunggul SN, and Muchamad Safaat, ‘The Politics of Indonesias Decentralization Law Based on Regional Competency’, Brawijaya Law Journal, 8.2 (2021), 159–84

Ramlan, Shazny, ‘Religious Law for the Environment: Comparative Islamic Environmental Law in Singapore, Malaysia, and Indonesia’, SSRN Electronic Journal, 15, 2019

Rian Saputra and Silaas Oghenemaro Emovwodo, ‘Indonesia as Legal Welfare State : The Policy of Indonesian National Economic Law’, Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 2.1 (2022), 1–13

Ridwansyah, Muhammad, and Asron Orsantinutsakul, ‘The Strengthening of Guardian Institutions in Nanggroe Aceh During the Autonomy Era’, Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 2.1 (2022), 55–65

Saputra, Rian, Muhammad Khalif Ardi, Pujiyono Pujiyono, Sunny Ummul Firdaus, Universitas Slamet Riyadi, and Universitas Sebelas Maret, ‘REFORM REGULATION OF NOVUM IN CRIMINAL JUDGES IN AN EFFORT’, JILS (JOURNAL OF INDONESIAN LEGAL STUDIES), 6.2 (2021), 437–82

Siboy, Ahmad, Sholahuddin Al-Fatih, Virga Dwi Efendi, and Nur Putri Hidayah, ‘The Effectiveness of Administrative Efforts in Reducing State Administration Disputes’, Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 2.1 (2022), 14–30

Silaswaty Faried, Femmy, Hadi Mahmud, and Suparwi Suparwi, ‘Mainstreaming Restorative Justice in Termination of Prosecution in Indonesia’, Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 2.1 (2022), 66–77

Trood, Michael D., Benjamin L. Spivak, and James R.P. Ogloff, ‘A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Judicial Supervision on Recidivism and Well-Being Factors of Criminal Offenders’, Journal of Criminal Justice, 74.October 2020 (2021), 101796

Wibowo, Mardian, I Nyoman Nurjaya, and Muchammad Ali Safaat, ‘The Criticism on the Meaning of “Open Legal Policy” in Verdicts of Judicial Review at the Constitutional Court Mardian Wibowo’, Constitutional Review, 3.2 (2018), 262


Article Metrics

Abstract view : 64 times
PDF - 23 times


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2022 Taufik Hidayat; Resti Dian Luthviati; Suviwat Jenvitchuwong

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System

Print ISSN: 2807-2979
Online ISSN: 2807-2812
Email: cc to
Published by: Lembaga Contrarius Indonesia
Office: Contrarius Indonesia Institute
Sibela Utara Street No.3, Mojosongo, Kec. Jebres, Kota Surakarta.